Skip to main content

The American Things I Defend. The Indian Things I Criticize

Watching Instagram reels made me laugh when I saw how fiercely immigrants defended the country they are in versus the country they are from. Almost seven years later, I became the woman who is here to defend the country I live in versus the country I'm from. When you are an immigrant, you learn the subtle art of contradictions. 

In India, separation is often mistaken for distance. Love arrives with questions attached. America taught me I have a right to the contents of my own life. My boss never asked me about my marriage, even when I'd be eager to tell my story. The cashier at Walmart did not pause enough to make a face when she saw my purchases. Silence in St Louis is never questioned, but respected, and I will gladly defend those boundaries, but I will criticize the loneliness it brings. Bombay is the city that never sleeps. You learn to sleep despite the chaos. Ask me the same question again at night, and I will tell you India overwhelms you with presence, but America overwhelms you with absence. 

A cozy bedroom bathed in warm evening sunlight, with an unmade bed, soft brown pillows, dried flowers on a bedside table, and window shadows stretching across the wall.

India gave identity to productivity. It was never, "What do I do for a living?", but "Where do I work?" People wore exhaustion as an accomplishment. I will defend America for drawing a line at 5 PM. When India was busy pursuing careers, America taught me the importance of hobbies. However, in the land of opportunity, we forgot how real loneliness can be and called it freedom.

India makes love concrete, edible, and real without needing an occasion. There was always an extra chair and an extra insistence to take more. The States taught me how to eat alone. Food stopped bringing people together, but then there is Hussain, the one who helps me in whatever way possible. Sometimes it is chopping onions, stirring the soup pot, or offering takeout Chinese. He has sat at the dinner table with me, eating food with his hands one day and soup dumplings with chopsticks the next, like neither identity threatened the other. Gatherings were inevitable in India; America scheduled them. 

I want the suffocating generosity with the respectful distance. It's contradictory, it's exhausting, and somehow still mine. I am choosing to hold all of it, all at once, and calling that enough. And when hard days hit, I can call Ammi to sit in silence together across 8,000 miles and, for a fleeting moment, just like home, make the presence and absence feel like the same thing.

A vintage wall clock illuminated by golden sunset light, with the shadow of a window cast across the wall, creating a quiet and reflective atmosphere.

Read Next:




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Two Sides One Coin

I need to keep my people with me forever. I hope I will hurt less someday. I wish to freeze time. I want to undo distance. Am I allowed to want joy again without it feeling like betrayal? Is it okay to laugh without grief immediately tugging my sleeve? Is it appropriate to live fully when I desperately miss my family back home?

What I Wish I'd Said Before I Left

I am barely a month shy of completing another year in the United States. I know this by memory; what I did not see coming is that the last hug would be the last one for years. If I had, I would have held on longer. I remember the honking of the cars at the airport, the smell of street food wafting in the air, and lingering just long enough for me to soak it all in for one final time. Bhai (brother) on a video call, bidding me adieu. Ammi (Mom) clutching my hands tightly. She had happy tears. I did not shed a single tear. Why would I? I was too excited to be with the love of my life in a little over 24 hours. My heart's only wish then was to see them make it to my wedding vows. That wish was never fulfilled. Today, I live with the grief of leaving Daddy's memories behind - tied to physical spaces. I see him when I make his favorite breakfast; I read him when I see the news; I see his lopsided smile when I get my numbers on my tax file correct, and I carry him in tears when I pra...

What is Love?

Growing up, my version of love was everything Bollywood portrayed: a damsel in distress who needed to be saved or a hero who would happily fight villains to marry the one he was in love with. And the couple lived happily ever after.  As I grew into a tantrum-throwing teenager, my idea of love changed. I saw it through the eyes of Ammi (Mom). She was a diehard romantic who loved colors, nature, romance, the idea of being in love forever, and everything dreams are made of. She believed it to be true. She believed it existed even if she didn’t get to live her fairytale. I saw her marriage to my father very differently, too. They were two entirely different people with two very different world views. One loved and lived through books, and the other saw and believed the reality of it.